Thursday, September 15, 2011

Elevation of Musicians

In his work The Genealogy of Morals Nietzsche makes a claim regarding the rise in the popularity of music, “There corresponded to this extraordinary rise in the value of music an equally amazing increase in the prestige of the musician: he now became and oracle, a priest, or more than a priest – a kind of mouthpiece of the absolute, a telephone line of Transcendence”(The Genealogy of Morals, 237). Many musicians today still get this sort of hero worship. I have never really understood it. I love a lot of bands and musicians but the height that some carry their love of certain person or group can become a bit extreme. Though I am in no position to judge any form of fandom, geek that I am, music seems to harbor a sort of religious element that pushes it to another level. The musician I am most familiar with who receives just the sort of priestly attention that Nietzsche describes here is Maynard James Keenan, lead singer of the bands Tool, A Perfect Circle, and Puscifer. Again while I am a huge fan I do not go as far as some and take the man himself so terribly seriously based on the music he produces. Others treat his work like religion. I tend to agree with Nietzsche earlier claim, “...let me say one thing at the start; it is always well to divorce an artist from his work, and to take him less seriously than it”(The Genealogy of Morals, 235).

This song gets particular attention for its metaphysical and spiritual content but really more or less just because it is written in numbers of fi. It is ten kinds of fantastic in my opinion, sure, but I wouldn't pray to it.

Thrice : Digging My Own Grave

"Here, in the highest symbolism of art, we see before us that Apolline world of beauty and the ground on which it rests, that terrible wisdom of Silenus, and we grasp, intuitively, the reciprocal necessity of these two things. At the same time, however, we encounter Apollo as the deification of the principium individuationis in which alone the eternally attained goal of the primordial unity, its release and redemption through semblance, comes about; with sublime gestures he shows us that the whole world of agony is needed in order to compel the individual to generate the releasing and redemptive vision and then, lost in contemplation of that vision, to sit calmly in his rocking boat in the midst of the sea." p. 26



ATB, Ecstasy

“But, at this juncture, when the will is most imperiled, art approaches, as a redeeming and healing enchantress; she alone may transform these horrible reflections on the terror and absurdity of existence into representations with which man may live. These are the representation of the sublime as the artistic conquest of the awful, and of the comic as the artistic release from the nausea of the absurd. The satyric chorus of the dithyramb is the saving device of Greek art."



Throughout his essay, Nietzsche constantly creates problems for Greek culture and art that he then solves with either the Apollonian or Dionysian element, or both, depending on the context. ATB’s Ecstasy portrays Nietzsche’s conviction that the Dionysian revelation cannot stand alone. Here, the Apollonian element helps reveal the essence of Dionysus by transforming the song’s enigmatic instrumental into an artistic phenomenon in the form of its accompanying lyrics. The upbeat tone, crisp layering, and memorable intro allow the listener to rise beyond consciousness and experience a connection to the primordial unity. However, the lyrics add a description of the feelings the song evokes and provides a sort of guideline for us to follow when listening to this song.

Al Jarreau- Take Five

Nietzsche's assertion about dithyrambic music as a, "miserable copy of a phenomenon and thus infinitely poorer than the phenomenon" (BT, 83)- because of its lack of myth as such- tells the reader that mimetic music fails to evoke or mirror world- Will as Dionysian music does. Just as Schopenhauer wrote in "On the Inner Nature of Art," Nietzsche points to the nothing-left-to-the-imagination aspect of mimetic music; Dithyrambic music is Schopenhauer's wax figure, a cheap representation. "Tone-painting is thus the antithesis of the myth-creating energy of true music... whereas Dionysiac music enriches and expands the original phenomena, making it into an image of the world" (BT 83). I believe Nietzsche is contradicting himself in this comparison. Al Jarreau's "Take Five" is, to me, an example of how Apollonian "form" (within a lingusic framework) entwines with Dionysian "frenzy" (manipulating language to express musical phrases, meaningful noise) to create a conversational piece of music that appeals to the world- Will because in "copying" phenomena (I hear stomach gurgles and crashing noises in Jarreau's trampled speech), he is also appealing to what-is-familiar, or doxa, evoking primal unity while reinforcing a kind of detachment thorough the irregularities in the beat. My main concern with Nietzsche is whether or not dithyrambic music is really exclusive from the Dionysian?

Murder City Devils - Boom Swagger Boom




"The essence of nature is bent on expressing itself; a new world of symbols is required, firstly the symbolism of the entire body, not just of the mouth, the face, the word, but the full gesture of dance with its rhythmical movement of every limb" (Birth of Tragedy 21). The symbolism of a hot girl is represented in this song by the onomatopoeia "Boom, swagger swagger" which works well to convey the raw carnality of desire without being overly explicit. Nature must express itself and we as animals ourselves know precisely what Spencer means when he says he saw the girl "walking like a cat." This line immediately conjures the image of a feline with its tail raised for all to view its inner workings; in other words an animal is always ready, open for the opportunity to perpetuate its existence. The Apolline work of civilizing the body through the mind's ability to reason  is circumvented by a song that forces one's body into motion. The denial of this innate knowledge seems to be the object of every project towards civilizing humankind as though by exhuming our sexuality we will somehow elevate ourselves from the animal world for good. I think this song does well in producing a visceral bodily reaction through words used merely as sounds and musical instruments used to convey seductive movements.
"The power of its sound to shake us to our very foundation, the unified stream of melody and the quite incomparable world of harmony. In the Dionysiac dithryamb man is simulated to the highest intensification of his symbolic powers; some-thing that he has never felt before urgently demands to be expressed: the destruction of the veil of maya, one-ness as the genius of humankind, indeed of nature itself."--The Birth of Tragedy, p. 21.



The video is the piece entitled "Cry" from Alvin Ailey's ballet, Revelations. The dance is set to a suite of three gospel songs: Alice Coltrane's "Something about John Coltrane," Laura Nyro's "Been on a Train," and The Voices of East Harlem "Right on. Be Free." Although Schopenhauer and maybe Nietzche would probably look down on the depictive/imitative qualities of these songs lyrically and perhaps melodically--I chose this particular video because to me it demonstrates the process of shedding of barriers and the slow taking over of the Dionysiac. The music seems to be working both within her and external to her--in moments she looks as if the music pulls her up off of her knees, thrusts her forward, and pulls at her limbs even as she tries to resist--like she is possessed by the music. The woman goes reluctantly but diligently through the motions forced by slavery/oppression (barriers created by man) and bursts of free, what looks like almost uncontrolled movement. To me this is the "destruction of the veil of maya," the forgetting of one's self and giving over to one's most primal urges--what Nietzche calls the nature of humankind. The self becomes utterly physical as the barriers (between man and man and man and nature itself) that are created by the mind melt away. Without these barriers, Nietzche notes that music compels us to express our true nature, and more so--to feel it and perceive it in the first place.

And just for kicks...if this isn't Dionysiac, I don't know what is...


Janis Joplin Live Woodstock

Brief Video on Woodstock 1969

Hendrix Guitar Sacrifice Monterey Pop Festival June 1969

Jimi Hendrix--Woodstock Star Spangled Banner

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/L3JbKimTdMg" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Hendrix Directly on Star Spangled Banner, Woodstock 1969

Hendrix on Music, Ego, Meaning and the Star Spangled Banner. Dick Cavett

A Question Concerning tech. . . science.

"What can the knowledge-lusting Socratism of today hope to do with this daemon as it emerges from unfathomable depths?"

Nietzsche, Birth of Tragedy p. 94

Knowledge-lusting is a nice play on wisdom loving (philosopher) and he's asking, reiterating in an interesting way, the problem our metaphysics has with the aesthetic. With music. Are we beasts, that music might move us so? Excite us to passion? Enthrall us in love? Music seems to directly link to a more emotional set of responses and is unfathomable, cannot be measured or known, by way of pure reason. It is an experience to undergo, not a fact to vivisect. To vivisect is to cut while alive (viv - life, sect - to cut. Interestingly secret and science share the same root) but to do such a thing is to kill it. To make it no longer what it was. And lo, we can proclaim we now know what beautiful music is, and hold proudly up to the light the individual pieces which were never meant to be so exposed. It would be like displaying the manifold parts of an elephant in an order of our cultural preference and saying "Behold, the mighty elephant in all it's explicable glory!"

Not everything is knowable in the way science knows things. Loathe though I may be to admit to having listened to Coldplay (long story) witness Coldplay's The Scientist. Somehow the song combines melody with today's logocentrism to produce what feels like a lament. Yet the question is, if no one said that it was easy, from whence that starting assumption we must disabuse ourselves.


Scene by Envy- Dionysus v Apollo


“Only the spirit of music allows us to understand why we feel joy at the destruction of the individual. For individual instances of such destruction merely illustrate the eternal phenomenon of Dionysiac art, which expresses the omnipotent Will behind the principium individuationis, as if it were, life going on eternally beyond all appearance and despite all destruction” (BOT 16)


‘Scene’ by the group Envy, is a song that seems, to me, to capture the struggle of the Apollinian forces and the Dionysiac Will. The song starts by keeping the individual within a state of principium individuationis- the beginning reveals the world of images and a the dream-like state of Apollo. In fact, the introduction seems as if it were a lullaby- allowing us to trust the stability of its calm melody. However, this stability is easily shattered as the tragic hero- the lead singer- soon screams with such an abrupt, deep pain and suffering. It as if the tragic hero is dying from a great suffering or sadness. This rips one (the listener) from the comfortable state of images and semblance and pulls one into the suffering of the Will- the Dionysiac state. The suffering within this melody is infused with the intoxication of the Dionysiac Will. It seems as if it will remain an eternal suffering- nothing could be greater than or overcome this state of chaotic passion.We, no longer as individuals, are caught in the struggle and suffering of the Will itself.

One can feel the utter desperation and destruction of the self within the singer’s cries, yet, at the same time a feeling of joy arises- at least a joy for the intensity of passions. “We take pleasure in the negation of the hero, the supreme appearance of the Will” (BOT 16).. His cries are beautiful (not in the sense of the beauty of appearance) and truly tragic.

And yet again, the calmness of Apollo reemerges as the Dionysus recedes behind the Apollinian semblance. Throughout the song, these too parts- between the calmness and the height of passions within the tragic cries of the lead singer- there is a constant struggle between the structure of Apollo and the intoxication of Dionysus: “Apolline and Dionysiac.. co-exist in a state of perpetual conflict interrupted only occasionally by periods of reconciliation (Birth of Tragedy 1).