This is a blog for the community of Rhetoric 108—On the Philosophy of Music: "Music to Hear"—in the Department of Rhetoric at the University of California, Berkeley, Spring 2011 and Fall 2011.
Thursday, September 15, 2011
Hans Zimmer - This Land
Although I don't think that Neitzsche would consider The Lion King as a tragic myth, and no doubt it would fall under the category of optimistic, I think the raw emotion of this score transcends the limits of the cartoon. The piece overwhelms me alternately with sorrow and hope, I forget its intentions as a background, and the music itself invades my mind. When I think of it in terms of the context of the movie, I can understand the theme of moods, the characters as illusions. The end of the piece, however, is what disqualifies it, and the The Lion King, as a true tragedy. The chanting and jubilation of the chorus implies hope and redemption, that the protagonist will find a way to prevail his circumstance, and Simba does.
Ours - Fallen Souls
Nietzshe's description of the Dionysiac as primordial reminds me of the driving drum beat throughout the song, while the intensity and urgency of the vocals evoke discomfort. The whole tone of the piece if foreboding, as if something terrible is about to happen. When the singer, Jimmy Gnecco, breaks into a scream, I do imagine the "worst possible world." Despite the tones of sorrow and pain, the song is undeniably beautiful, the vocals astounding. The Dionysiac drum beats prompt me to hear beyond the sounds, while the pain in the vocals ground me in familiar. I think here is illustrated the dual existence and reliance of Dionysiac/Apollonian elements in tragedy. See Comments for lyrics
Blcokhead - The Music Scene
I mostly associated Nietzsche's words with the animation to this song more so than the content of the song itself, but I certainly think that there's something sublime in the track and something dionysiac in the rhythm. The opening sample, the titular "music scene" seems ironic given the dreamy, upbeat quality of the song and so appears even more apt to me given Nietzsche's contrasting dualities of pessimism and optimism. It's music that has movement, but none that might be frantic. There's also a pretty direct reference to drugs that connects the music to intoxication of one form or another. In any case, I think the music in conjunction with the visuals captures the above quote pretty well.
Wednesday, September 14, 2011
Schopenhauer's take on Memory
“Finally, it is also that blessedness of will-less perception which spreads so wonderful a charm over the past and the distant, and by a self-deception presents them to us in so flattering a light. For by our conjuring up in our minds days long past spent in a distant place, it is the only objects recalled by our imagination, not the subject of will that carried around its incurable sorrows with it just as much then as it does now”(138).
This excerpt from Schopenhauer's "The Artist and the Sublime" struck me as a fairly peculiar take on the subject of memory and its relation to beauty and truth. While often we see a negative critique of the persistence of memory and the polishing effects nostalgia imposes on our experiences Schopenhauer seems take an opposite stance on the process of memory. Though memory adorns past experiences with falsehood and self-deception Schopenhauer claims that at the same time has a stripping effect on the subject of our recollection and only the Idea remains. We all have had the experience of connecting certain songs with moments time and events in our life. One song which I think may be subject to this stripping effect for me is Blind Melon's "No Rain". This was my first favorite song. I can remember how my brother and I would go across the street to our neighbor's, Tim and John, house and play co-op "Diddy Kong" on Super Nintendo and listen it on repeat for hours. Looking back I cannot remember conversations I had with them or my brother at the time or very many other activities we did together besides play "Mortal Kombat", "Independence Day", or whatever action movie had come out that week in our yards(both back and front), but listening to this song seems to capture and embody the truth of those moments without the adornment of details. The song simply feels like the joy of being 5 or 6 or 7 to me. It evokes in me that special knowledge and perspective that only kids have though I can no longer hope to articulate it merely experience, it reflect on it.
Jay Z - Big Pimpin'
Indeed, the first movement, having come into being, is threatened by a "painful destruction" (1:48) and "we are forced to gaze into the terrors of individual existence," we become aware of two individual forces at odds with one another. But once our senses settle and the violence brought on by kick drums pounding 32nd notes, the rage and distorted cry of guitar and voice, we notice the original melody is still there "behind them." We notice this song is "the struggle, the agony, the destruction of appearances," appearances which we took to be the original melody on its own. Then listening on, we notice more, that the song is the interplay between forces, and "uncountable excess of forms" that thrust and push at one another. The purely musical fights to be heard from behind the brutality of guitar and drum and voice. We listen on and realize there is more to be heard, that we realize the two forces are one, that the guitars are indeed playing the original melody, that they are not two "individuals" but "the one living being," that are we.
Tuesday, September 13, 2011
La Vida Es Un Carnaval - Celia Cruz
"No, you should first learn the art of comfort of this world, you should learn to laugh, my young friends, if you are really determined to remain pessimists" (Nietzsche The Birth of Tragedy, 12).
Arguably one of Celia Cruz's seminal pieces, this song describes laughter being being the key to the enjoyment of life, much like Nietzsche expresses to his pessimistic readers. The song is, in my opinion, incredibly uplifting and cheerful.
Monday, September 12, 2011
Miss Kittin & The Hacker - Frank Sinatra (Full Version no bullshit)
Thursday, September 8, 2011
There Is No There- The Books
Diamanda Galas--"Double Barrel Prayer"
Classically trained as an opera singer, Galas' voice has an abnormally large range and is very powerful. She uses this voice, however, in a manner that exceeds the bounds of her training. The source of her music and her art is a response to the AIDS related death of her gay poet brother in the early 80's. Her style can definitely be considered abnormal and devoid of what Schopenhauer would characterize as sufficient reason. Her voice becomes an instrument to convey her outrage and pain. She shrieks, quotes the bible and speaks in tongues to symbo0llically convey the holiness and majesty of her mourning. Schopenhauer sees music as a means to spiritually distract one from the pain of the will. Galas seeks to strangle the will with her suffering.
On Shostakovich: Symphony No. 5 in D Minor: To Read with Paige Posting
Shostakovich: Symphony No. 5 in D Minor
Dmitri Shostakovich, 1906-1975. Symphony No. 5 in d, Op. 47. Completed 1937, first performance November 21, 1937, in Leningrad. Scored for 2 flutes, piccolo, 2 oboes, 2 clarinets, E flat clarinet, 2 bassoons, contrabassoon, 4 horns, 3 trumpets, 2 trombones, bass trombone, tuba, 2 harps, piano, celesta, tympani, snare drum, bass drum, cymbals, xylophone, glockenspiel, triangle, and strings.
The late 1930's were not a good time for Dmitri Shostakovich. His successful opera, Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk, was banned after Stalin saw it in 1936 and was offended by its veiled criticism of the Communist regime. This was no small matter; most who drew the dictator's wrath soon died in a labor camp. Shostakovich was luckier, perhaps because the young composer had already achieved some international recognition, but the attacks in Pravda turned him into a pariah who began keeping a packed suitcase beside his bed in case he were arrested in the night.
Shostakovich's next misstep came with the Fourth Symphony, which he had been composing in his mind for some time. Despite the risk of associating with an ``enemy of the people,'' the Leningrad Philharmonic agreed to premiere it, but the rehearsals went badly, and it became clear to Shostakovich that a performance of such a forward-looking work would be dangerous to his life. In December of 1936, he announced that it was a failure and withdrew it, ostensibly to work on the finale. The Fourth was lost during the war, and it was only in 1961 that it was reconstructed and premiered exactly as written.
Meanwhile, Russia was undergoing what would later be called the ``Great Terror.'' For his own reasons, Stalin had concocted an assassination and then responded to it with a level of repression rarely seen in human history. After he declared that five percent of the population was ``unreliable,'' orders went out that the number of arrests must match this figure. Guilt was irrelevant; it was sufficient to round up ten or fifteen thousand people from a given town and send them off to Siberia. Historians disagree on the exact number of Russian citizens murdered during this time (partly because many of the deaths were later blamed on World War II), but it was certainly in the millions.
In such an atmosphere, and with a wife and two young children to worry about, it was only natural that Shostakovich would pull his head back into his shell and try to please the authorities. And so he did, at least on the surface: the Fifth Symphony's subtitle is ``A Soviet Artist's Practical Creative Reply to Just Criticism.''
But throughout history, artists have thumbed their noses at authorities who were too dense to see through their parody and satire, and Shostakovich was no different. One does not need to look far beneath the surface of the Fifth to discover just what this ``practical'' reply actually contains. The first movement begins with a cry of despair, a tragic lament that goes on for some time before suddenly being interrupted by a goose-stepping march led by a two-note tympani theme, a motive that musicologist Ian MacDonald calls the ``Stalin theme.'' The third movement is one of the most despairing pieces of music ever written, a memorial for Mother Russia and all those sent to the labor camps. And of the finale, Shostakovich wrote in his memoirs (smuggled out of Russia after the composer's death):
What exultation could there be? I think it is clear to everyone what happens in the Fifth. The rejoicing is forced, created under threat... It's as if someone were beating you with a stick and saying ``Your business is rejoicing, your business is rejoicing,'' and you rise, shaky, and go marching off, muttering, ``Our business is rejoicing, our business is rejoicing.'' What kind of apotheosis is that? You have to be a complete oaf not to hear that.The Fifth was hugely successful. The government was pleased that the rebel had knuckled under, while the Russian in the street saw the truth behind the facade. Western listeners, generally unaware of what was going on behind Stalin's mask, took the work at face value, yet were still overwhelmed by its grandeur and beauty. The symphony has become Shostakovich's most popular work, and the relatively recent revelation of its true meaning can only enhance our enjoyment of this testament to one man's struggle to express his people's anguish under a brutal tyrant.
© 1997, Geoff Kuenning